Connect with us

law an courts

Justice minister, Legal Practice Council oppose Zim-born law graduates' court challenge – News24

Bruce Chakanyuka, Nyasha James Nyamugure and Dennis Tatenda Chadya want to practise law in SA.

Bruce Chakanyuka, Nyasha James Nyamugure and Dennis Tatenda Chadya want to practise law in SA.

SimpleImages, Getty Images

  • Three Zimbabwean-born law graduates, who have fully qualified in South Africa, are challenging a rule that prevents them from practising law in SA.
  • According to the Legal Practice Act, only permanent residents and citizens may be admitted to the profession.
  • The Scalabrini Centre is opposing the Legal Practice Council’s stance, stating that its submissions to the court are “premised on the most vulgar of stereotypes and are simply xenophobic”.
  • The Legal Practice Council states that it does not believe the relevant section of the Act is unconstitutional.
  • A Department of Justice representative has also argued that the legal profession is not a rare or critical skill and that many South African citizens struggle to get work.

South Africa’s Legal Practice Council (LPC) and the Minister of Justice are opposing a court bid by three Zimbabwean-born graduates to change legislation which bars them from practising law in South Africa.  

Bruce Chakanyuka, Nyasha James Nyamugure and Dennis Tatenda Chadya, with the assistance of the Asylum Seeker Refugee and Migrant Coalition, launched a constitutional challenge to the Legal Practice Act (LPA), GroundUp reports.

The Act provides only for the enrolment and admission of attorneys and advocates who are either citizens or have permanent residence permits. The three graduates have permits which allow them to live, study and work in South Africa. They have also completed their degrees, written board exams and done their articles and pupillage.

The matter is pending before the Gauteng High Court in Pretoria.

Three other organisations, the Scalabrini Centre of Cape Town, the Pan African Bar Association and the International Commission of Jurists, have lent support to the applicants’ plight. They have asked to be admitted as amicus curiae (friends of the court).

The Scalabrini Centre, which promotes and protects the rights of asylum seekers and refugees, has strongly opposed the LPC’s stance, stating that its submissions to the court are “premised on the most vulgar of stereotypes and are simply xenophobic”.

In an affidavit, Scalabrini Centre executive director, Giulia Treves, refers to the “extremely concerning justifications” put forward by the LPC in an attempt to justify the blanket exclusion from the legal profession of those who are not citizens or permanent residents.

These include that asylum seekers and refugees are allegedly incapable of acting as officers of the court and with high ethical standards; that they are not fully committed to attaining justice within South Africa; they do not respect the laws of South Africa; they do not have the necessary appreciation of South African institutions; and they are incapable of being regulated by the LPC. It also states that they are an unreliable drain on the country’s resources.

Treves says it’s important for the centre to get involved in the matter to ensure that the voices of this vulnerable group of people are heard.

In opposing documents, LPC chairperson Kathleen Matolo-Dlepu, says it does not believe the relevant section of the Act is unconstitutional. She points out that the LPC is not the “custodian” of the Act, but merely ensures that legal practitioners comply with provisions. She says the relief that the applicants are seeking is essentially against the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services.

Matolo-Dlepu adds:

Opening the floodgates of persons who wish to practise as attorneys or advocates may lead to abuse, particularly by those who will suddenly be entitled to practise in South Africa by simply obtaining a work permit … this will prejudice legal practitioners who have been admitted to practise.

She also says the courts “should not be burdened with requests to determine policy”. Temporary residents are not prevented from working in the legal sector, but only exempt from being admitted as officers of the court, she says.

“The legal profession involves extraordinary obligations to duty and conscience and requires the highest ethical standards … in order to fulfil their role in the administration of justice and in our society, legal practitioners must be fully committed to South African society. Only citizenship and permanent residency imply such full commitment.”

On behalf of the minister, Kalayvani Pillay, a deputy director in the department of legal services, suggests that the Department of Home Affairs be included in proceedings because the case deals with immigration laws.

Pillay says the legal profession is not a rare or critical skill and many South African citizens struggle to get work.

Nasreen Rajab-Budlender, the national chairperson of the Pan African Bar Association – which set up the Pius Langa School of Advocacy – says that if admitted as a friend of the court, it will submit that the exclusion of non-citizens is akin to apartheid policies.

– Originally published on GroundUp.

We want to hear your views on the news. Subscribe to News24 to be part of the conversation in the comments section of this article.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

law an courts

Covid News Live Updates: Maharashtra reports its first case of Omicron variant; India tally reaches 4 – Economic Times

!1 New UpdateClick here for latest updates

Jaisalmer | PM made a very big decision that cards be issued to CAPF jawans & their families. Through that, they & their families can avail treatment at any hospital for any disease. With a swipe of the card at the hospital, the process will begin: HM at Rohitash Border outpost

Man, who returned from foreign country, to Kalyan Dombivali municipal area near Mumbai, tests positive for Omicron variant of coronavirus: Maha health department director.

Maharashtra man who travelled to Mumbai from South Africa via Dubai, Delhi found positive for Omicron; 4th case in India: Official sources

France imposed new rules on travelers from outside the European Union to slow the spread of the omicron variant

Assam CM HB Sarma today announced names of 19 personalities chosen for 3 newly-instituted awards- Asom Baibhav, Asom Sourav & Asom Gourav, “to honour their exemplary services towards society”

Cyclonic Storm Jawad weakened into a Deep Depression at 1730 hrs IST of today, it is about 180 km east-southeast of Vishakhapatnam (Andhra Pradesh), 260 km south of Gopalpur (Odisha , 330 km south-southwest of Puri (Odisha) and 420 km south-southwest of Paradip (Odisha): IMD

Odisha: Some people take refuge in a shelter home in Puri set up by the state government in wake of Jawad Cyclone

As per the latest update by IMD, the cyclonic storm would weaken gradually during the next 6 hours, and reach near Puri around 5th December noon as a Deep Depression.

Employment is going to be the biggest issue in these elections. I give you a guarantee that within a short span of time we’ll give you a vision. All men have eyes, few have vision..:

– Punjab Congress chief Navjot Singh Sidhu in Amritsar

Scope of Indo-Pak trade & these 34 countries is US$ 37 Billion. Right now we’re carrying out trade of only US$ 3 Billion, not even 5% of the potential. Punjab has suffered loss of Rs 4,000 Cr in last 34 months, 15,000 jobs lost:Punjab Congress chief Navjot Singh Sidhu in Amritsar

People of Delhi only contribute to 31% of the total pollution. We need to make joint action plans along with NCR cities to overcome this issue. The entry of trucks is banned in Delhi, schools are closed and no construction work is allowed: Gopal Rai, Delhi Environment Minister

Bihar | Operation Theatre and Medicine shop of the local eye hospital in Muzaffarpur sealed after multiple patients lose eyesight following cataract surgery a few days ago

Senior journalist Vinod Dua passes away, confirms his daughter and actress Mallika Dua. His cremation will take place tomorrow, she posts.

Leaders of all farmer orgs said that they won’t go back unless cases against farmers are withdrawn. Today a clear cut signal has been sent out to Govt that we’re not going to take back the agitation unless all cases against farmers are taken back.

– Farmer leader Darshan Pal Singh

SKM says farmers will not move from protest sites till government withdraws cases registered against them during stir against farm laws.

Delhi reports 51 new COVID-19 cases, 61 recoveries and zero deaths in the last 24 hours.

Total cases 14,41,295
Total recoveries 14,15,875
Death toll 25,098
Active cases 322

Following first case of Omicron in Jamnagar, Gujarat CM Bhupendra Patel reviewed the readiness of state health system, at a high-level meeting. He instructed to strictly implement new guidelines issued by the Government of India regarding Omicron variant in the state: CMO

West Bengal | Police baton-charge on youth who were not standing in a queue to submit forms for jobs in the Berhampore Stadium of Murshidabad district

Delhi court grants bail to Peter Mukerjea in INX Media money laundering case

The Jawad Cyclone was observed moving northwards in the past 1 hour &will continue the same for the next 12 hours. Weakening trend in the intensity of the cyclone & expected to hit the coastal regions of Puri tomorrow and will weaken gradually.

– HR Biswas Director IMD Bhubaneshwar

SKM has formed a 5-member committee to talk to the Govt of India. It’ll be the authorised body to talk to the Government. The committee will have Balbir Singh Rajewal, Shiv Kumar Kakka, Gurnam Singh Charuni, Yudhvir Singh & Ashok Dhawale. Next meeting of SKM on 7th December

– Rakesh Tikait

Odisha | In view of Cyclone Jawad, one team has been deployed here in Puri. If the situation worsens here, we have all the rescue equipment and team ready for that: NDRF officer Biswanath Choudhary

BWF World Tour Finals | Shuttler PV Sindhu beats Japan’s Akane Yamaguchi to enter the final of World Tour Finals 2021

Rajasthan | Union Home Minister Amit Shah offered prayers at Tanot Rai Mata Mandir, Jaisalmer

Omicron-concerned Singapore stops VTL travel for work pass holders

  • The decision by the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) comes in the wake of rising concern over the Omicron variant globally.
  • On Friday, Singapore had announced the tightening of rules for VTL travellers in view of the new variant (Omicron).
  • The S Pass allows mid-level skilled foreign staff to work in Singapore.

Pakistan’s Punjab province witnesses surge in dengue cases

India vs New Zealand 2nd Test: Kiwis all out for 62

  • New Zealand trail by 263 runs
  • Ravichandran Ashwin takes four wickets for 8
  • Mohammed Siraj claims 3 for 19 runs

India vs New Zealand: Kiwis lose ninth wicket, at 62-9

BJP in talks with Amarinder, Dhindsa for alliance in Punjab: Amit Shah

A person is found omicron positive in Jamnagar. We’ve isolated him & are monitoring him. A micro containment zone has been made where he is living. In the area, we will do the tracing, testing of people

– Manoj Aggarwal, ACS, Health & Family Welfare Dept, Gujarat

These political parties have come up with a way to make the public helpless, dependent & not strong. They want the public to be penurious so that their own crown stays in place

– PM Narendra Modi in Dehradun

India vs New Zealand: Kiwis lose two wickets in succession

  • NZ now at 53 for loss of eight wickets
  • Need 73 runs to avoid follow on

India vs New Zealand 2nd Test, day 2

  • New Zealand 38/6, trail by 287 runs at tea, at Wankhede Stadium in Mumbai.
  • Mohammed Siraj takes 3 wickets for 19 runs

Omicron in Gujarat

  • This is the first case of Omicron variant in Gujarat
  • The case was found in Jamnagar
  • The person came from Zimbabwe; his sample has been sent to Pune, said State health department
  • This is the third case of Omicron variant in the country.

Jamnagar man who returned from Zimbabwe found infected with Omicron variant of COVID-19: Gujarat health department

Russia confirms 32,974 new COVID-19 cases over past 24 hours

Our mountains & culture are not only our faith but also the fortresses of our country’s security. We prioritize ease of living for people living in the mountains. Unfortunately, it was nowhere in the policy strategy of those who remained in power for decades

– PM

Our government has constructed a national highway of more than 2 thousand kilometers in Uttarakhand in its seven years: Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Between 2007 and 2014, the central government built only 288 km of national highways in Uttarakhand in seven years: PM Modi

Today, I am very happy that the foundation stone of the Delhi-Dehradun Economic Corridor has been laid. When it is ready, the time taken to travel from Delhi to Dehradun will be almost halved

– PM Modi at Dehradun

Explosion occurs in Afghanistan’s capital Kabul

According to the witnesses, the blast occurred on Kabul’s Fifth Taimani Street, Tolo News reported. No casualties have been reported so far. Further details are awaited.

Smart City project envisages 5.5 km heritage corridor in Jammu

The heritage trail, being set up under the project ‘Heritage trail and site beautification’ will stretch 5.5 kilometre and will cost Rs 16.56 crore, officials said on Saturday. They said the JSCL held discussions with various stakeholders to seek their support for the project.

Chargesheet against former police commissioner Param Bir Singh

Mumbai Police Crime Branch Unit 11 to file chargesheet against former police commissioner Param Bir Singh and others in Goregaon alleged extortion case today. Singh had recorded his statement in the case last week.

SKM’s meeting to map further course of farmers’ agitation starts

Modi set to inaugurate & lay the foundation stone of multiple projects worth around Rs 18,000 crores in Uttarakhand today

I’d like Directorate of Revenue Intelligence to be more active in preventing drugs smuggling & detecting toxic wastes that come into India, in time

– FM Nirmala Sitharaman

PM Modi inaugurates Delhi-Dehradun Economic Corridor

We have a preliminary report on Omicron, I’ve given directions on cluster management in schools, colleges & apartments. I have also instructed BBMP (Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike) commissioner to look into gathering in apartments’ common areas

– Karnataka CM Basavaraj Bommai

New Zealand’s Azaj Patel takes all 10 wickets in the innings

India all out for 325

Indraprastha Gas revises CNG rates in three states, w.e.f today

  • CNG price in NCT of Delhi to be Rs.53.04/- per Kg.
  • Gurugram price set at Rs.60.40/- per Kg.
  • CNG price in Rewari Rs.61.10/- per Kg.
  • Karnal & Kaithal prices at Rs.59.30/- per kg
  • Ajmer, Pali and Rajsamand CNG prices now Rs.67.31/- per kg.

Chhatrapati Shivaji International Airport reduces RTPCR rates

CSMIA has revised the rates of Rapid PCR test at a reduced cost of INR 3900 as against INR 4500 earlier.

AP CM Jagan, Chandra Babu Naidu mourn Rosaiah

Andhra Pradesh Governor Biswabhusan Harichandan, Chief Minister Y S Jagan Mohan Reddy, Leader of Opposition N Chandrababu Naidu and a host of others on Saturday expressed profound grief over the demise of Konijeti Rosaiah, who served as the CM of the then united AP.

Former Andhra Pradesh CM Konijeti Rosaiah passes away at 89

Centre clears production of 5L AK-203 rifles ahead of Putin visit

The 7.62 X 39 mm caliber AK-203 Rifles will replace in-service INSAS Rifle inducted over three decades back. AK-203 Assault Rifles, with an effective range of 300 meters, are light weight, robust and easy to use Modern Assault Rifles with proven technology that will enhance the combat potential of soldiers to adequately meet present and envisaged operational challenges.

Agarwal’s century run continues for India vs New Zealand

Opener Mayank Agarwal extended his fifth test century total to 146 and was still at the crease as India moved to 285-6 at lunch on the second day of the second cricket test against New Zealand on Saturday. Left-arm spin bowler Ajaz Patel has taken all six wickets for New Zealand.

Continuous rains witnessed across the district, windspeeds of 50kmph at few locations; 79 cyclone shelters operation since yesterday. NDRF, SDRF, fire teams on alert and deployed across the district

– Andhra Pradesh officials

The visit of Russian President Vladimir Putin will take place on 6th Dec. He will be here for the 21st India-Russia Annual Summit. There will be a series of meetings. We foresee a very intensive engagement during the day and culminating with the Summit

– Ministry of External Affairs

Cyclone weakens after heavy rain, evacuation in southern India

  • A tropical storm weakened after dumping heavy rains overnight in parts of southern India off the Bay of Bengal as more than 50,000 people evacuated to government-run camps, officials said Saturday.
  • No loss of life or major damage has been reported so far from the rain-hit areas of Andhra Pradesh state.
  • Kanna Babu, a state commissioner for disaster management, said 54,000 people who evacuated on Friday from vulnerable areas were waiting in nearly 200 state-run relief camps for the weather to clear before returning to their homes.

Omicron: Parliamentary panel recommends evaluation of vaccines

Amid growing concerns over the Omicron variant of SARS-CoV-2, a parliamentary committee has recommended that the efficacy of Covid vaccines must be evaluated and the government conduct more research to examine the need for booster doses to contain the new strain. The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Health, which presented its report on Friday, also said that concerns with regard to the new strain developing immunoescape mechanism should be critically addressed.

Omicron: Karnataka instructs medical colleges to be prepared

  • Amid concern over the new COVID-19 variant ‘Omicron’ and possible third wave, Karnataka Health Minister Dr K Sudhakar said that the state has instructed medical colleges across the state to make necessary preparations for every possibility.
  • After chairing a video conference meeting with the directors of the medical colleges, on a possible third wave and the new Omicron virus-related treatment, the minister said, “There are 21 medical colleges offering health services at the district level. Everyone, including the HOD, Professors and senior doctors of medical colleges have been advised to stand up to the demand and provide effective treatment.”

India reports 8603 fresh Covid infections

Continue Reading

law an courts

Explained: The second violent run-in for Sri Lanka in Pakistan and lessons for India – The Indian Express

Priyantha Diyawadana Kumara, from Gampaha district near Colombo, an engineer and father of two, was on Friday beaten to death and his body burnt by a mob of hundreds, some of the workers at his factory, who accused him of committing blasphemy.

From the Prime Minister, to the chief of Army Staff, and others, even minister Sheikh Rasheed, a proud supporter of jihadist extremism, all stood unequivocally united in the condemnation of the incident, and promised swift action.

While Pakistan’s progressive civil society has always stood against such incidents as going to the core of what is broken within, this is perhaps the first time that a killing in the name of blasphemy has elicited such unanimous and unequivocal condemnation from the political class and the powerful army.

The strong official reactions may be due to the fact that the victim was a foreign national, from a South Asian country with which Islamabad has gone the extra mile to build ties. Pakistan is hyper-conscious about projecting a progressive image abroad.

This is the second time in the last 15 years that Sri Lanka, which has fair people-to-people ties with Islamabad, has found itself wrong-footed by Pakistan’s extremist violence. Pakistan is only too conscious of this. In the world of cricket, it is still paying a heavy price for the attack on the Sri Lankan team bus in 2009 – other than the Zimbabwe team last year, Pakistan has not since been able to host a single foreign team, with the Kiwis too pulling out in September this year after a security alert.

But even at the time of the cricket bus attack, the strong ties between the two countries cushioned bilateral relations. Colombo has little regard for the IPKF. It remembers more the “parippu drop” over Jaffna, when the Indian Air Force dropped food supplies to Tamils when the Sri Lankan army had laid siege on the northern peninsula in 1985, but it has never forgotten that Pakistan provided weapons and munitions and trained Lankan Air Force pilots for Sri Lanka’s war against the LTTE.

Sri Lanka was subdued in its reaction to the killing of Priyantha Kumara. It took a full day for President Gotabaya Rajapakasa to break his silence and tweet that he was “deeply concerned by the incident in Sialkot #Pakistan. #SriLanka trusts that PM @ImranKhanPTI and the Gvt. Of Pakistan will ensure justice is served and the ensure the safety of the remaining Sri Lankan workers in Pakistan”. Before that the Sri Lankan foreign ministry asked Pakistani authorities to “take the required action to investigate and ensure justice”. Earlier, Foreign ministry spokesperson Sugeeshwara Gunaratna said the Sri Lankan High Commission in Islamabad was in the process of verifying details of the incident from Pakistani authorities.

Pakistan has promised swift action against the perpetrators. Some 100 people said to be part of the mob and two of the main instigators have been arrested, the Pakistani media have reported.

However, Pakistan’s regressive and draconian anti-blasphemy law is loaded against the person against whom the allegation is made. In well-known cases that attract international attention and are thought to be spoiling the country’s already fragile image abroad, the system steps in to protect the alleged blasphemer, sometimes with prodding from western powers, and if there has been violence, to hand out punishment to the perpetrators.

Aasia Bibi

The most famous example of the way this law, the law enforcers, the government, and the judicary work is that of Aasia Naureen, better known as Aasia Bibi, who was arrested in 2009 after her co-workers alleged she had committed blasphemy. She was sentenced to death by a lower court. The punishment was confirmed by the Lahore High Court. It was only under tremendous international pressure at a time that Pakistan was negotiating an IMF bailout, that the Supreme Court took her review petition and ruled there was not enough evidence against her.

Protests broke out at the acquittal, roads were blocked by extremist groups such as Tehreek-eLabbaik. Aasia had to remain in custody for the next six months because of fears she would be killed. Prime Minister Imran Khan had to make repeated assurances that she would not be allowed to leave the country. Finally, she had to be spirited away from Pakistan to Canada secretly.

Unlike Aasia, in many cases, alleged blasphemers may not live to see jail or a courtroom, and their killers go scot-free. In the rare cases where punishment to the perpetrators is handed out, they are celebrated as “gazi”, religious warriors by the military-backed politically vocal and visible sections of Pakistan’s religious, conservative Muslims.

Mumtaz Qadri, the police bodyguard who was hanged for the 2011 killing Salman Taseer, the governor of the Punjab province (who was accused of blasphemy for speaking up in support of Asia Bibi) is held up as a martyr. The silent majority of Sunni Muslims may not support such glorification even if they are staunch believers, but they are silent.

Qadri’s execution led to the founding of Tehreek-e-Labbaik, which regularly holds the government to ransom by bringing out its supporters on the streets. During one such protest in 2017, the ISI brokered a deal between the group and the government of the day, making the government pledge that it would not dilute anti-blasphemy laws. The government had to recently lift a ban on the group.

Mashal Khan case

In March 2017, Pakistan was convulsed just as it is now by the killing of a 23-year-old journalism student in a college in Mardan, in Khyber Pakthunkhwa province. Mashal Khan and two of his friends had been accused by fellow students of posting blasphemous content online. They were attacked on campus by students and Mashal Khan was lynched. His friends escaped with injuries.

Nawaz Sharif, then prime minister of the country, condemned the incident as saddening and senseless, and asked the entire country to stand together to promote tolerance in society, but a month earlier, he called it an “unpardonable offence”. It was the outpouring of public solidarity for him, the huge turnout for his funeral, and the strong reaction in his village to the killing that put pressure on the police to round up the killers. In all 61 people were arrested, one was sentenced to death, and seven others to life imprisonment by an anti-terrorism court.

Junaid Hafeez

In 2014, Rashid Rehman, a well-known human rights lawyer defending an accused in a blasphemy case, was shot dead. His killers have never been brought to justice. Rehman’s client, Junaid Hafeez, a university teacher, who was arrested in 2013, was sentenced to death in 2019 by the lower court, where a blasphemy case rarely ends in acquittal. In the trial courts, judges fear for their lives if they let an accused go. Mostly judges delay the cases till their transfer. Law enforcers, witnesses, jailers all worry for their safety in blasphemy cases.

Just in September, a 50-year-old Muslim woman was sentenced to death for an alleged blasphemous act in 2013. The woman, who was a school principal was accused by a local imam for describing herself as a “prophetess”. In January, three men were convicted of blasphemy for sharing allegedly blasphemous content on social media, the first case of conviction for online blasphemy in Pakistan. With a precedent set, the next month, a woman was accused of forwarding allegedly blasphemous material on WhatsApp.

Section 295A: The blasphemy law

In September, the Human Rights Commission of Pakistan expressed concern at the surge in blasphemy cases being registered. It said 40 cases had been registered in August alone. According to estimates by NGOs, some 1,800 cases of blasphemy have been registered since 1977, when the blasphemy law was made stricter.

Law enforcers know Section 295A of the Pakistan Penal Code which deals with blasphemy is widely misused by religious fanatics against members of minority communities – Ahmadi, Shia Hindus Christians – and against Muslims too, to settle personal scores. For the accused, prison is often a safer place than freedom as they live under constant threat to their lives. Just this week, two days before the Sri Lankan’s killing, a mob burnt down a police station in Charsadda in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa where a man who had allegedly torn up a Koran was being held. The police had refused to hand over the man to the mob which was baying for his blood outside, growing in size as the day progressed. The police had to flee the station along with the man just before the station went up in flames.

Pakistan inherited Section 295 A from the colonial-era 1927 anti-hate speech section in the Indian Penal Code following the Rangila Rasool episode. In the Zia era, this section was further expanded to cover more offences under blasphemy and the death sentence introduced as one of the penalties (India has kept the original section). Some believe that the death sentence encourages people to take the law into their own hands for instant “justice”.

Newsletter | Click to get the day’s best explainers in your inbox

No Pakistani politician wants to take the risk of trying to repeal the blasphemy laws, though most recognise that it is not in keeping with the image of modernity that the nation wants to project. Even the military ruler Pervex Musharraf backed off though he gave it serious consideration. Now as then, it is considered politically unwise and personally hazardous. Years of pandering to extremists has literally disabled the Pakistani state on this issue.

Cautionary tale for India

Pakistan’s experience on its blasphemy law is a cautionary tale for those who want to bring similar laws in India. Despite all advice, Punjab enacted a blasphemy law in 2018 to appease religious sentiment after several cases of sacrilege of the Guru Granth Sahib. Disrespect shown to the Sikh holy book, the Bhagvad Gita, Bible and Koran are all punishable with life imprisonment. An earlier legislation brought in by the Akali Dal did not get presidential assent as it was specific to the Guru Granth Sahib, and it was returned with the comment that all religions are to be treated equally. The All India Muslim Personal Law Board’s recent demand for an anti-blasphemy law has received a strong push back from within the Muslim community, with prominent voices warning against the dangers of such a law. In a statement signed by more than 400 people, a majority of them Muslim, the Indian Muslims for Secular Democracy said there was no need for such a law as Muslims had every right to invoke Section 295-A in the Indian penal Code to deal with any complaints. The statement pointed to the “notorious blasphemy law in neighbouring Pakistan which is frequently used to hound individuals from religious minorities and even fellow Muslims with sectarian and personal motives”.

Continue Reading

law an courts

Return woman film-maker's impounded passport: Madras HC – Times of India

CHENNAI: Madras high court has quashed a Chennai regional passport officer (RPO) order impounding the passport of woman film-maker Leena Manimekalai, and directed him to release it within a week.
The passport was impounded in view of a pending criminal defamation complaint filed by film director Susi Ganesan and ‘adverse report from law enforcing agency’ against her. Susi Ganesan filed the case after she levelled #MeToo allegation against him.
Justice M Dhandapani reversed the order, saying: “For an offence, alleged to have been committed under Section 500 (criminal defamation) of IPC, that too on a private complaint, the passport, without any rhyme or reason, after a lapse of four years from the date of issuance of passport has taken the extreme step of cancelling the passport of the petitioner.” The act of the passport authority appears to be very strange. Offences of criminal nature, which have far-reaching consequences and more penal in nature, which affects the society, wherein persons who have committed such heinous offences, being holders of passport, in such of those cases, seldom the passport authority, invoke such powers, Justice Dhandapani said.
“This does not augur well with this court. However, judicial discipline warrants this court to refrain from dealing any further on this aspect,” the judge added. Allowing her plea, the judge said: “Section 10 (3) (e) of the Passports Act pertaining to pendency of criminal proceedings in any court of law committed by the holder of the passport is pressed into service to claim that the pending criminal case before the trial court was the reason for impounding the passport.”

Continue Reading


One Zimbabwe Classifieds | ZimMarket

Zimbabwe Market Classifieds | ZimMarket

1 Zimbabwe Market Classifieds | ZimMarket

Linking Buyers To Sellers Is Our Business Tradition